OK people, "we conclude that much of the problem with illegal sharing of copyrighted material has been caused by the rightsholders, and the music industry in particular, being far too slow in getting their act together and making popular legal alternatives available. We do not believe that disconnecting end users is in the slightest bit consistent with policies that attempt to promote eGovernment, and we recommend that this approach to dealing with illegal file-sharing should not be further considered".
Now, not my words, but the words of the All Party Parliamentary Communications Group, one of those cross-party clubs within parliament which concerns itself with issues relating to a certain theme, in apComms' case telecommunications, mobile phones and the internet (in fact three separate groups, one for each of those areas, merged to form the current apComms in 2007). Their thoughts on file-sharing appear in a general document discussing internet issues, and is based on evidence given by interested parties in July, ie before Peter Mandelson's Business Department started talking tough about online piracy.
Their viewpoint, which obviously differs from that held in government circles since August, probably isn't a surprise. All party groups, and to a certain if lesser extent parliamentary select committees, often tend to favour the viewpoints of their core target constituency. In apComm's case that is the internet service providers and tel cos, who have generally been very clear where they stand on this issue - piracy is all the record companies' fault, and net providers shouldn't have to step in to help combat it. That said, the net firms might point out they don't agree with everything in the new apComms report, so the group isn't that biased. And more optimistic music execs might say that neither they nor Mandelson are actually proposing all out "disconnection" for file-sharers, so the report's recommendations don't totally fly in the face of the Government's current thinking.
Is apComms' summary of the file-sharing situation fair? Well, as always, yes and no. Certainly the record industry floundered for years on the internet issue, throwing money in the direction of lawyers and digital rights management makers when they should have been supporting, honing and developing compelling legit digital services, and reinventing their artist partnerships to generate new income streams for both talent and label. And if only record label execs had paid attention to their CMU Daily, that's exactly what they would have been doing.
But for well over three years now the record industry has been making gallant moves towards licensing, enabling and supporting compelling digital music services, so that today there is a whole load of choice out there. True, issues remain. Gaps in digital catalogue, the big upfront payments the majors often demand from new digital services, and the inevitable truth that today's popular digital platforms will require the labels to radically rethink their licencing structures to be viable long term. Not to mention issues around the reporting and payment of digital royalties to artists.
But, nevertheless, the record labels have been playing ball for a few years now, and all the great new music services that have arrived in the last year are a result of that. If ISPs or political types refuse to act on online piracy simply because the labels were slow to respond to the internet, well you're basically beating record companies up for albeit bad decisions made five years ago, but since retracted. (It's also unfair to single out the music industry in the copright domain - if anything, the music business is way ahead of the TV and film studios, and book, magazine and newspaper publishers, who are only now grappling with the opportunities and threats of the net).
Either way, while the apComms report may not be overly favourable to the record industry, the Public Affairs chief at record label trade body the BPI, Richard Mollet, has found one reason to be optimistic about their findings. According to Music Week, he says that elsewhere in the report the group say ISPs should take proactive steps to detect and remove "inappropriate content". Mollet says that one of the MPs in the Group, Derek Wyatt, has told him unlicensed content would fall under that banner. Mollet adds: "The fact that recognises ISPs take increased responsibility for what goes on its network is positive". So there you go.
Of course none of this is hugely relevant really given Mandelson will almost certainly ignore most of what apComm's report says (let's remember, he's doing a pretty good job of ignoring much of a similar report his own government commissioned - Steve Carter's 'Digital Britain'). Not only that, but unless Mandy can get new anti-filesharing rules onto the statute book extra speedily, it looks increasingly likely that it will the posh boys of Team Cameron who will ultimately decide whether new laws are needed to enable copyright owners to thrive in the digital age.