Oct 20, 2009 • 2 min read

PCC will investigate Gately complaints

The Press Complaints Commission will ask the Daily Mail to respond to complaints about Jan Moir's column on Stephen Gately's death, which drew 22,000 complaints.

The Press Complaints Commission has said it will ask the Daily Mail to respond to complaints about the previously reported column by Jan Moir, in which she suggested there was more to the death of late Boyzoner Stephen Gately than had been so far reported, and that his sudden demise was probably due, in part, to a lifestyle influenced by his homosexuality. Moir added that his sudden passing brought to an end what she called the "happy-ever-after myth of civil partnerships".

As previously reported, by Friday lunchtime the Twittersphere was full of outrage over Moir's piece, not so much because it was a terribly written incoherent argument that even a Mail journalist should be ashamed off, but because of the homophobic undertones of her guess work and resulting observations. The more savvy outraged bloggers - and other journalists, including The Guardian's Charlie Brooker - urged everyone to target the Mail's advertisers and the UK newspaper industry's self-regulation body, the PCC.

This being the era of easy-complaint, by late Friday the PCC was reporting it had received over 1000 complaints about Moir's Gately piece, and that its website had collapsed because so many people were checking out how to formally complain. By Monday afternoon the Commission confirmed it had received 22,000 complaints, making Moir's column the most complained about article in the PCC's history - it generating more complaints in one weekend than the whole body had received in the last five years.

As reported yesterday, unlike, say, OfCom or the BBC Trust, the PCC is not mandated to respond to general public outrage and exists primarily to deal with complaints by people who feel they have themselves been unfairly treated in a newspaper. However, the Commission confirmed yesterday that it would ask for a response from the Mail regarding the piece even if no complaint was made by the Gately family.

A spokesman told reporters: "If, for whatever reason, those individuals do not wish to make a complaint, the PCC will in any case write to the Daily Mail for its response to the more general complaints from the public before considering whether there are any issues under the code to pursue".

The Commission added that it had been in touch with representatives of Boyzone regarding the piece, and that they were speaking to Gately's widower and family about the matter. The spokesman added: "Any complaint from the affected parties will naturally be given precedence by the commission, in line with its normal procedures".

Bloggers have identified a number of PCC rules that it could be argued Moir breached in her column, most notably, of course, the one that says "the press must avoid prejudicial or pejorative reference to an individual's race, colour, religion, gender, sexual orientation or to any physical or mental illness or disability".

Former Fleet Street editor Janet Street-Porter used her own Daily Mail column to criticise Moir's comments. Noting that a number of bloggers accused Moir of basically saying Stephen Gately "died of being gay", and referencing the recent murder of civil servant Ian Baynham in a seemingly homophobic attack in central London, she wrote: "Being gay killed a man last week - but he wasn't Stephen Gately".

Meanwhile the Irish edition of the Daily Mail, possibly aware that if outrage takes off over there it could actually hit their sales, was keen to distance itself from the whole thing, with editors saying yesterday: "Comments made by journalist Jan Moir about Stephen Gately in her newspaper column caused controversy on Friday. Jan Moir's column has never been published in the Irish Daily Mail which, like the Irish Mail On Sunday, is edited and printed entirely in Ireland - independent of the UK titles - and does not have an online presence".

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy