Jul 16, 2009 • 2 min read

People still like CDs, shocker

Research by The Leading Question found most music fans still prefer CDs to downloads, though a blog argues file-sharing may have shifted offline rather than declined.

Sometimes it's too easy to assume the CD is already dead in the water, but while the format is clearly in decline, it's still pretty dominant. And, according to that previously reported research report from the Music Ally people and their research outfit The Leading Question, a majority of people still prefer buying CDs to downloading MP3s - and even teenagers aren't especially down on the physical format.

As previously reported, The Leading Question spoke to a thousand music fans about their buying habits. 73% of those surveyed were happy buying CDs rather than downloading, while 59% said they still listen to music on CDs on a daily basis. Perhaps most surprisingly, 66% of teens said they prefer CDs to buying music via download stores.

The Leading Question's Tim Walker told CMU: "Digital is still the future but rumours of the death of the CD are premature. The continued popularity of the CD should be looked upon as an opportunity. We believe that labels and online stores could and should be doing more to build on music fans' familiarity with CDs to provide them with additional digital content and to use the CD as a bridge into the digital world".

In related news, a blog post on the Fleeing From Pigeons website is pretty critical of this here Leading Question/Music Ally report, in particular the previously reported conclusion that file-sharing is down in the UK. As previously reported, the Leading Question research revealed that of the 1000 music fans interviewed, only 17% said they accessed music via unlicenced file-sharing networks at least once a month, compared to 22% the last time they did the survey in late 2007. File-sharing was down in the teen demographic too, from 42% to 26%. But, the FFP blog reckons, that's as much to do with the researchers' definition of 'file-sharing' as anything else.

As previously noted here, the growth in high capacity webmail accounts in recent years, plus the falling price of high capacity portable hard drives, means that a lot of people now share files with friends by emailing MP3 attachments or syncing hard drives in the playground/union bar/workplace. While file-sharing this way means that files are only shared from one friend to another, rather than from one P2P user to 5 million other P2P users, email-to-email or device-to-device file-sharing is still significant, and, crucially, generally untracked by the record companies (the latter being impossible to track without some sort of horrid digital rights management attached to music files).

FFP reckon that these other kinds of file-sharing were not included in The Leading Question's stats. Meaning file-sharing, especially among younger music fans, might not be in decline, it's just going offline.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy