Apr 20, 2005 • 1 min read

Picking holes in past testimonies: Jacko trial update

Jackson's defence lawyer Thomas Mesereau challenged the credibility of Janet Arvizo, mother of the accuser, over a previous lawsuit and her injury photographs, though the prosecution's position remains unclear.

Anyway, enough of all that ? copyright law is so incredibly dull. Back to a more interesting court case, and another morning of Thomas Mesereau / Janet Arvizo banter. As the Michael Jackson trial continued yesterday, so did Mesereau's attempts to portray Arvizo, the mother of Jacko's current accuser, as a money grabbing charlatan.

Much of the morning was spent going over a previous lawsuit that the Arvizo family brought against a store security guard in which Mrs Arvizo claims she was assaulted and molested. Jacko's legal team want to prove that that incident was a con that won the Arvizo family a $150,000 settlement ? the (albeit suspect) logic being, of course, if she conned the system then, she will be conning the system now.

Having already admitted that she lied to the court during that case when she denied that her then-husband beat her, Mesereau took her up on other parts of that testimony. Of particular concern were photos that Arvizo's lawyers claim show the injuries Janet suffered during the altercation with the store security guard. When asked when the pictures were taken, Arvizo said ?straight away? after the assault. To which Jacko's lawyer responded: "But didn't you testify that you didn't have these bruises immediately?" Mrs Arvizo fumbled for a while, before saying she couldn't remember exactly when the pictures were taken, because it had been handled by her lawyers. Referring to the admission that her ex-husband did hit her, Mesereau suggested the bruises in the pictures were as a result of a run in with him rather than a store security guard, to which Janet responded "That's incorrect?.

As previously commented, Mesereau did, to a certain extent, succeed in damaging the credibility of Janet Arvizo during her five days in the witness stand. Doing so is crucial to Jacko's legal team's defence case. However, despite some contradictions and a tendency to ignore questions and address the jury directly, Mrs Arvizo's testimony wasn't disastrous for the prosecution and, as she stood down and Gavin Arvizo's grandmother took to the witness stand, it is still hard to say which side, if any, is gaining momentum as the case continues.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy