Universal's Polydor Records - Boyzone's record label - have filed a complaint over Jan Moir's now infamous Daily Mail column discussing the death of Stephen Gately, which was seen by many as both offensive and homophobic. As previously reported, it leapt to unsubstantiated conclusions about the late pop star's death, and suggested his demise was in part due to his "gay lifestyle", adding that the incident eradicated the "myth of happy ever after civil partnerships". Whatever that means.
As previously reported, thousands of people have submitted complaints to the Press Complaints Commission since the column first surfaced last Friday, at last count 25,000. Although the PCC only usually steps in when an individual personally connected to an offending article complains - in this case that would be Gately's widower or family - the Commission has confirmed it has asked the Daily Mail to respond regarding the piece.
Whether a complaint from Polydor, whose direct connection with Gately was professional rather than personal, will have any more significance than those from the 25,000 others who have complained to date isn't clear. A Commission spokesman told the Guardian: "The PCC is now considering this new complaint".
Even if Polydor's complaint, or the other 25,000, do lead to a fuller investigation on Moir's piece, many media commentators don't expect the Commission to take any actual action against the Mail, and not just because the tabloid's editor Paul Dacre chairs its Code Of Conduct committee.
Discussing the various allegations that have been levelled against Moir and the Mail by those who have complained to the PCC, Roy Greenslade wrote in his media column in the Evening Standard this week: "Though Moir's allegations rest on supposition without a shred of provable evidence, and therefore meant that her reading of the situation was probably inaccurate, it was clearly speculation. Her piece was laced with innuendo that seemed to betray homophobia, but it is going to be tough to make the discrimination charge stick. As for intrusion, unless Gately's family formally complain, it's hard to imagine the PCC agreeing with third-party complaints on that basis alone".
Many of the media commentators discussing the Moir furore also seem to be of the opinion that the Commission shouldn't take any action against the Mail, because while what she said may have offended thousands, the Commission in itself does not exist to stop newspapers offending people (nor to stop columnists submitting badly written incoherent arguments).
Greenslade makes a comparison with the debate around the BBC inviting BNP big cheese Nick Griffin onto it's 'Question Time' show tonight. If you believe, as most media commentators do, this is the right thing to do on freedom of speech grounds, even though you might find most of what Griffin says deeply offensive, then probably the same approach should apply to the Mail and Moir. He concludes: "However distasteful it is to put up with homophobic journalists and racist politicians, censorship does not remove prejudice. It drives it underground, a greater threat to democracy than reading and listening to offensive points of view".