Oct 9, 2009 • 3 min read

Provisional commission ruling opposes LiveMaster merger

The Competition Commission has provisionally ruled that the proposed Live Nation and Ticketmaster merger would hinder competition, particularly the entry of CTS Eventim into UK ticketing.

The Competition Commission has made a provisional ruling that the proposed merger of live music conglom Live Nation and ticketing giant Ticketmaster will hinder competition, which is a bit of blow for management at the two merging firms. As previously reported, the two company's merger proposals were referred to the UK's competition authority by the Office Of Fair Trading back in June, mainly based on a complaint by another major player in the ticketing industry, CTS Eventim.

CTS have been very involved in the establishment of Live Nation Ticketing, the live music firm's own in-house ticketing division, launched at the start of the year after the company's old deal with Ticketmaster ran out. Live Nation Ticketing had not long launched in the US when the LiveMaster merger proposals were first announced.

Live Nation use CTS technology for their own ticketing enterprise, and in Europe were all but outsourcing their new ticketing service to the German company. Through that partnership CTS, who havn't previously had much of a presence in the UK, were planning on entering the British ticketing market.

While CTS initially issued a statement saying they'd had assurances the LiveMaster merger proposals would not affect their ten year deal with Live Nation, the German firm subsequently told the OFT the merger would force them to abandon their plans to enter the UK ticketing market. As CTS's arrival over here would have increased competition in the ticketing sector by adding another major player into the mix - arguably to the consumer's advantage - that concerned the OFT, and seems to have concerned the Competition Commission also.

In their provisional ruling, the Commission says: " that, if the merger were to proceed, Live Nation would have the incentive to impede CTS's entry into the UK ticketing market, in particular by minimising the supply of its tickets to CTS, and thereby frustrate CTS from becoming an additional effective competitor to Ticketmaster. This could lead to higher net prices (eg due to lower rebates to promoters and venues) and/or lower service quality and/or less innovation in the market than would otherwise be the case".

The Commission suggests a number of remedies that would overcome its concerns, from the severe (the combined LiveMaster sells off the UK operations of either Live Nation or Ticketmaster) to the less so (LiveMaster agrees to ensure one or more third party ticket agencies have rights to sell tickets to a majority of Live Nation's tours and venues).

Responding to the provisional ruling, CTS said it couldn't comment, while, in a joint statement, Live Nation and Ticketmaster insisted that their merger was needed to safeguard the future of a flagging music industry.

Their statement said: "Live Nation and Ticketmaster respect the Competition Commission for its analysis of the merger and have cooperated, and will continue to cooperate, fully during this ongoing process. Both our companies are committed to this merger and look forward to addressing any and all issues that the commission deems necessary, but we must be clear about the challenges of the music industry, which is at a decisive crossroad. The recording industry is a shell of its former self. Where the recording industry was once the economic engine for the music business, it is live entertainment that is now the future of the music industry".

It added: "We believe this merger will build a more efficient and effective company moving forward, and that working together we will be able to help achieve needed change that will strengthen a flagging music industry. During the course of this merger process, Live Nation and Ticketmaster have listened to our fans, artists and other stakeholders. We've heard a range of views regarding the issues and challenges facing the live music industry. We firmly believe that our merger achieves an important and much needed public interest, and remain optimistic that it will ultimately be approved".

The Competition Commission will continue to consult on the merger until the end of the month, I think to expand on the proposed remedies that would alleviate the authority's concerns. It will issue its final report on the matter on 24 Nov. The merger is also being investigated by the US Department Of Justice, of course. US and UK authorities are thought to be consulting each other on the merger.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy