Mar 25, 2009 • 3 min read

PRS launch website in ongoing YouTube squabble

PRS For Music has launched a website in its dispute with YouTube, after Google blocked premium music videos in the UK over a failed licensing negotiation.

PRS For Music have taken their battle with YouTube to the internet, which seems like as good a place as any to fight it. The songwriter royalty collecting society has launched a new website called www.fairplayforcreators.com and, possibly aware that their side of the dispute with the Google-owned video service enjoyed more media attention than might have been expected thanks to the fact the squabble went public the week various artists were doing the rounds of the news studios to promote their new Featured Artist Coalition, the PRS have got some of their better known songwriting members involved with the venture.

As much previously reported, earlier this month Google announced it was blocking access to premium music videos on YouTube in the UK because it had failed to negotiate a new licensing agreement with PRS. The net firm said that PRS were being unreasonable in their licence fee demands, and that they could never cover the costs of licensing music at those rates through advertising sales. PRS argued that they were only asking for the fees as set out by the UK Copyright Tribunal when it last ruled on digital royalties, and stressed that they had not asked for any music to be removed while talks were ongoing, arguing that the move was a sneaky negotiating tactic, an attempt to win public support - by implying to YouTube users that "PRS is stopping you from getting your videos" - in a bid to strong arm the collecting society into accepting lower rates.

Announcing the launch of the website this morning, the collecting society restated their position regarding the YouTube squabble. They said in a statement: "On Monday 9 March 2009, internet giant Google began denying UK music fans access to premium music videos on YouTube - the video sharing site it bought for $1.65bn in 2006. Google claimed this was a move to highlight its ongoing licensing negotiations with PRS For Music - the not-for-profit organisation owned by songwriters and composers which licenses content on their behalf. A PRS licence is a legal requirement for any business wishing to play, perform or reproduce music".

They continue: "Google's decision to remove premium content was made unilaterally, without any consultation with PRS, and indeed, PRS did not wish them to remove content In our view this was a tactic by Google to try to influence the commercial negotiation. In reality, it only punishes the music fan and the songwriter/creator. Understandably, many music fans in the UK are confused and angry at Google's decision. The members of PRS - the composers and songwriters of the music that has been removed from YouTube - share UK music fans' concerns".

The statement concludes: "It cannot be in anyone's best interests to block access to music. Fans are denied enjoyment, creators aren't paid and illegal music sites benefit from the resulting displacement of web traffic. Composers and songwriters did not ask for their music to be removed from YouTube, nor would they expect Google to continue to benefit from operating a service that relies so heavily on their music, without properly recognising and rewarding them for providing it".

According to the PRS, the new website is partly part of a campaign to pressure Google to reopen access to music videos on the YouTube UK website while the two side's licensing talks continue, and partly an effort to convince the public that "composers and songwriters should earn what they rightfully deserve from the use of their music in the online space" and that royalties such as those that they want from the video sharing service are important in "nurturing creative music talent".

Among the songwriters supporting the new site are Jools Holland, Pete Waterman, Robbie Williams collaborator Guy Chambers, 6Music-presenter-come-songwriter Tom Robinson, Eastenders-theme-tune-writer Simon May and Abba's Bjorn Ulvaeus, who, of course, recently entered the royalty debate in a column about the Pirate Bay trial in his own country, in which he wrote about those who prefer to use free but illegal sources of music: "Is it really so damn difficult to pay your way?"

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy