Media group EMAP, owners of Kiss FM and numerous local commercial stations, last night warned the latest government concession on radio ownership could be a "pyrrhic victory" if the role of new regulator Ofcom's with regards the radio industry was not better clarified. The latest concession says that only two (and not three) commercial radio groups must trade in each area, meaning each group can own more stations in each city. But EMAP bosses say forthcoming media legislation is still very vague when it comes to radio mergers.
"This is a good start, but it could be a pyrrhic victory," Tim Schoonmaker, the chief executive Emap Performance (the groups music division which oversees its radio stations) told the Media Guardian. "What we really want to know is how will Ofcom behave as a competition regulator. We need to get into the detail of how Ofcom will operate. We are months away from Ofcom even having a chief executive."
This was backed up by a radio analyst in the city - Simon Mays-Smith of JP Morgan - who said: "The 'two plus one' rule is better than the original 'three plus one' rule, it will make things a lot easier and the market's reaction will be positive. But the whole communications bill has to be looked at under the enterprise bill - the new competition law - and radio could run into difficulties there. For example, in London, under the 'two plus one' rule, Capital and Emap could get together, leaving Chrysalis plus the BBC. But Capital has 45-55% or London's advertising market and if it merges with one of the other companies, it will have a major share of total radio advertising. Competition law may go against that." Mays-Smith reckons that a similar situation may occur in most other major cities meaning competition legislation would prevent any of the mergers the communications bill seems to allow.