Jul 26, 2005 • 3 min read

SonyBMG admit to payola

SonyBMG has admitted some employees bribed US radio executives for airplay, and agreed to a $10 million fine after an investigation by New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer.

So, those previously reported rumours that SonyBMG was about to say "fair cop guvnor" in New York Attorney General's ongoing investigations into payola activities in the US music radio sector proved to be true yesterday, when both the legal man and the major label made formal statements to that effect.

This all relates to the investigation kicked off by New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer last year into allegations record labels were bribing US radio execs to get their artists valuable airtime - a practice banned by American media law. At the time the record companies were keen to distance themselves from pay-for-play radio promotion tactics, using words like 'thing of the past' and 'isolated incidents'. However SonyBMG's admission yesterday that some of its employees were guilty of bribing radio execs suggests that, while the prevalence or scale of payola is nothing like it was in the seventies, a lot more of it goes on that many senior industry types have been willing to admit.

Confirming SonyBMG had admitted to using some payola tactics, Spitzer told reporters yesterday: "Our investigation shows that contrary to listener expectations that songs are selected for airplay based on artistic merit and popularity, air time is often determined by undisclosed payments to radio stations and their employees. This agreement is a model for breaking the pervasive influence of bribes in the industry. Aggressive promotion of products is one of the hallmarks of our economy. We expect it and respect it when done creatively and legally. But the efforts outlined [here] clearly crossed the line and must be curtailed".

Among the 'efforts outlined' in Spitzer's report on SonyBMG's radio promotion activity are evidence of the major:

- bankrolling radio station giveaways.

- making payments to radio stations to "cover operational expenses".

- purchasing "spin programmes" - airplay under the guise of advertising.

- making payments to middlemen 'promoters' - suspected to be a cover up for illegal payments to radio stations.

- handing "outright bribes to radio programmers" including expensive gifts and all-expenses-paid holidays.

SonyBMG have said they will act to stop all payola activity undertaken by their employees, and that they will pay a $10 million fine as punishment for the pay-for-play violations they have already committed. Their statement, which closely followed Spitzer's, ran thus: "Despite federal and state laws prohibiting unacknowledged payment by record labels to radio stations for airing of music, such direct and indirect forms of what has been described generically as 'payola' for spins has continued to be an unfortunately prevalent aspect of radio promotion. SonyBMG acknowledges that various employees pursued some radio promotion practices on behalf of the company that were wrong and improper, and apologises for such conduct. SonyBMG looks forward to defining a new, higher standard in radio promotion."

Don Rose, President of the American Association of Independent Music, welcomed SonyBMG's admission and Spitzer's ongoing investigations, pointing out that the independent sector cannot afford to compete once the majors start using expensive bribery to secure airplay. Rose told reporters: "This settlement is important because it sheds light on a process which has traditionally excluded the indie label community. We believe that there will be increased opportunity for our sector as a result. With a level playing field, the airwaves can better reflect the impact of indie labels and artists. We look forward to the development of an environment where great music, regardless of its source, has equal opportunity to be heard."

It remains to be seen what actual moves SonyBMG boss Andrew Lack now makes in order to combat the payola problem (presumably most of the guilty players have ceased their more obvious pay-for-play tactics ever since Spitzer announced his investigation). More importantly, it remains to be seen which of the other major record labels have to follow suit with admissions, commitments and fine payments in order to placate Spitzer.

And, of course, what of the major radio companies who are allegedly accepting these payola payments? US media regulator the FCC issued its own statement yesterday praising (somewhat excessively) Spitzer's investigation, and implying it will be taking action of its own against the bribable radio stations. FCC Commissioner Jonathan Adelstein told reporters: "It's a real tribute to AG Eliot Spitzer that he has blown the lid off a potentially far-reaching payola scandal. I've been expressing concern about this for some time in terms of enforcing our federal rules, but it took someone with Spitzer's tenacity and subpoena power to bring forward solid evidence. We've seen a lot of smoke around payola for a while, but now we know it's coming from a real fire. It's time to dump a bucket of cold water on it. It's unfair to listeners if they hear songs on the radio because someone was paid off, not because it's good music. We need an immediate investigation to determine whether these practices violate federal payola laws. I've asked Mr Spitzer to share all of the evidence that he has uncovered with the FCC."

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy