Sweden's Data Inspection Board (DIB) has ruled that the country's anti-piracy group, Antipiratbyran (APB), broke personal data legislation when they tracked down which individuals had been illegally sharing copyrighted content online.
Earlier this year thousands of Swedes reported the APB to the DIB after the anti-piracy body began its campaign against individuals illegally filesharing via P2P networks. The problem was that the technology used to track illegal filesharing stored each user's IP address on a central database. Because those users did not give their permission for such data to be stored, and because the APB was a private organization, some claimed the anti-piracy group was violating the country's data protection rules.
APB's lawyers argued IP addresses did not constitute personal data, so therefore the storage of IP addresses was not covered by data protection law. But last week the DIB disagreed, ruling the APB's actions unlawful. However the data protection body would not go as far as to say the APB had committed an offence, with a spokesman telling Swedish website The Local: "It depends on how you assess the significance of what they did. If it classed as a minor infringement then it is not punishable".
APB didn't comment on the DIB's ruling, but were keen to stress they had already stopped using the data collection method that violated data protection law, adding that the decision would not affect their efforts to stop online piracy. The group's lawyer, Henrik Pontén, told reporters: "We have other methods than storing IP addresses for tracing people who break copyright laws concerning films and games".