Sweden's justice minister, Thomas Bodström, has thrown his weight behind those European consumer rights bodies who criticise record labels for using copy-protection technology on CD releases, threatening to make the use of such technology illegal in the country unless the industry reviews its copy-protection policies. Anti-piracy technology used to control which devices consumers can listen to music on has been controversial for some time now. Critics claim that when someone buys a CD they should be able to transfer the music on it to which ever device they prefer - even if that means making copies. They also point out that anti-piracy technology frequently has the side effect of stopping music from playing properly, or at all, on certain CD players or PCs.
Bodstrom was speaking to Swedish Television's website ahead of a debate in the Swedish parliament on proposals to introduce tough new laws to tackle illegal downloading and sharing of copyrighted content online. The minister says he backs those proposals, but adds that moves to protect the rights of authors, artists, musicians, composers and film-makers must be balanced against the rights of people who have paid to enjoy their work.
Bodstrom: "Obviously it should be possible to make a copy of your own newly-purchased CD for an MP3 player, or to make an extra copy of the CD to have in the car. When the copyright is strengthened, it is extra important that this doesn't reduce the options to copy legal material for private use, through the copyright owners "locking" material with copy blocking. The industry must ensure that the option to copy for private use is not hindered by technical means."
Representatives of the music industry have told the media that they agree in principle with what Bodstrom says, pointing out that only one record label in Sweden still copy protects its CDs. Magnus Mårtensson, a lawyer at the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry, told reporters: "We totally agree with Bodström. The whole point is that you should technically be able to do the copying you're allowed to do. Two years ago this was more of an issue, but now there is only one record label in Sweden which still copy protects its CDs."
Nevertheless, Bodstrom says the government plans to look into the use of copy prevention technology following the debate on downloading and sharing laws this week. And I've got a stack of copy-protected CDs that really bugger up my PC that he can start with.