At another SxSW panel, regarding that holy grail, finding a way to monetize P2P, there were mixed opinions on both the viability and desirability of finding a way to make file sharing pay - most probably by charging a file sharing levy onto ISP bills.
As previously reported, some argue that no legit a-la-carte download service, or subscription-based or ad-funded streaming or all-you-can-eat download service, is ever going to truly compete with the concept of P2P file sharing among young net users. Therefore, rather than continuing with trying to stop file-sharing, through litigation against those who assist in it (LimeWire, The Pirate Bay etc) or who actually do it, or by lobbying for the controversial three-strike rule to be applied to internet access, record companies would be better off trying to find a model that makes P2P pay.
The most likely model is the ISP file-sharing levy. The system is not without its problems though. Do you apply the levy to all, which content owners have a right to a share of the money, how is content sharing monitored and royalties distributed, and does such a system completely degrade the value of music?
Most of those issues were raised by panellists at the SxSW 'Is Collective Licensing For P2P File Sharing A Future Source For The Music Industry?' debate.
Warner consultant Jim Griffin was there to talk about his previously reported Choruss project, which will introduce the levy system within the college sector in the US, whereby universities will pay a content levy (passed onto students through their fees) meaning that students using their college internet connections can file-share legally. Some speculate that Choruss, if it works, could be a forerunner of a more mainstream P2P levy platform. Griffin, though recognising the possible future development of Choruss, wouldn't be drawn on specific future plans.
Others on the panel had concerns about the 'collective licensing for P2P' model. McGill University's Sandy Pearlman wondered if a licensing system based on tracking file sharing was already outdated, raising the growing 'dark internet' and the growth of device-to-device sharing as possible problems. Music lawyer Dina LaPolt worried that however good tracking and royalty distribution systems might be, the system would never be perfect and emerging talent would lose out.
Meanwhile, Rick Carnes, President of the Songwriters Guild of America, argued that giving a green light to all file sharing, even if there was a levy income attached, was not desirable, because to the consumer it gave the impression all music should be free. According to Billboard he told the session: "If music is free, you don't get music that is good, you get music that is free".