Dec 14, 2009 • 3 min read

Terra Firma sue Citigroup over their EMI acquisition

Terra Firma has sued Citigroup in New York, alleging the bank withheld information that rival bidders for EMI had dropped out before its 2007 acquisition.

Isn't it funny how those vastly over paid City boys sometimes justify their offensively large pay packets by saying that they deserve them because of the risks they take and the responsibility they saddle, but then when the shit hits the fan they look for others to bail them out, and blame everyone else for any risky decisions they took that backfired big time.

Although, to be fair, Terra Firma and its chief Guy Hands are probably shifting the blame for their disastrous EMI gamble more to strengthen their negotiating position rather than to absolve themselves of blame for a big bold deal that has seriously backfired.

So, yes, Terra Firma are suing the financial backers of their EMI purchase back in 2007, Citigroup. The lawsuit, filed in the New York court last week, comes after months of negotiations between the private equity firm and the American bank.

As previously reported, with EMI struggling to even meet the interest payments of the Citigroup loan Terra Firma saddled the music company with as part of its 2007 acquisition of the firm, Hands wanted the bank to write off about a billion of the major's debts, in return for a commitment by his equity group to pump a similar amount into the company to safeguard its future and enable further restructuring.

Terra Firma are tired of having to hand over more cash to EMI in order to help it meet its interest payments. Of course, the deal Hands put to Citigroup would require his company to pump even more money into the music major, but at least that would be to fund further development rather than just to keep the bailiffs away from the door. And a dramatic reduction in EMI's overall debt would help boost the value of Terra Firma's portfolio, the overall value of which has slumped as a result of the equity outfit's failure to turn round EMI's fortunes.

But, as previously reported, Citigroup has knocked back all of Terra Firma's debt restructuring proposals to date, hence the lawsuit.

So, what have the equity boys got on the bank? Well, they reckon Citigroup execs provided misinformation to Terra Firma prior to the EMI purchase, or, rather, they failed to give Hands and his team the crucial information that all rival bidders for the major, and in particular Cerberus Capital Management, had dropped out of the running.

Thinking that there were still rivals, Team Terra Firma upped their offer. The equity firm's lawsuit says Citigroup deliberately misled them because the bank was providing services and loans to both them and EMI, and reaped greater rewards by seeing a successful higher-offer Terra Firma acquisition going through.

Citi are basically accused of having a conflict of interest in the EMI deal. Big banks often do have conflicts of interest in major deals like this - because it's common for banks to be providing differing services to two sides of one deal - but it's assumed execs inside the bank act responsibly. Most probably do, but when an equity firm like Terra Firma falls out with its bank, then the conflict of interest card is always there ready to be played.

As well as bad behaviour before the EMI deal, Terra Firma are also accusing the bank of more recent improper conduct. They say the bank has been trying to destabilise EMI, because they'd rather see the music company collapse. That way, as sole backer of Terra Firma's acquisition, they could seize the major's assets and sell them off to recover the money they lent - possibly to a Warner Music-led consortium.

Terra Firma say that Citigroup's outright refusal to restructure EMI's debts was motivated by the desire to see the music company collapse. Said accusations may have been aided by an analyst, in another bit of Citigroup, recently saying that a merger with Warner was basically the only way EMI could avoid bankruptcy. Such observations, while possibly valid, won't be welcomed by Terra Firma, especially given reports that - having failed to renegotiate the music firm's debts with Citigroup - they are now charming other City institutions to try and rally up new investment for EMI.

Some commentators have remarked that for Hands to sue Citigroup, a bank he has partnered with for years, is a sign of just how bad things are at EMI. The recent Beatles re-issue campaign coupled with Robbie William's new album means that the recordings division of the major - where most of the losses are usually made - has been performing a little better over the last few months. Some reckon that, as a result, EMI will be able to meet its next Citigroup interest payment without needing another bail out from Terra Firma. But clearly Hands sees nothing but doom and gloom at the music company for the year to come, hence the drastic measures.

Citigroup, for their part, deny all the allegations made against them in Terra Firma's lawsuit. The bank might claim that by suing for $1.5 billion in damages over the alleged misinformation, Terra Firma are trying to strong arm them into writing off $1 billion of EMI's debts, as the equity firm had wanted. Either way, those who reckon EMI will soon only exist as a division of the Warner Music Group have an ever increasing pile of evidence in support of their claim.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy