Nov 12, 2009 • 2 min read

Three-strikes through the back door via world treaty?

Leaked documents suggest a global treaty under discussion in the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement talks could include three-strikes rules and restrictions on ISP safe harbour protections.

Forget about the role of the European Union in the fight against online piracy, could a global treaty up there with the big copyright conventions of Berne and Rome obligate governments the world over to force internet service providers to become the piracy police, and make the at times controversial three-strikes system law in most countries?

Well, perhaps. A not-much-reported conference of ministers from around the world focused on the trade and distribution of more traditional counterfeit goods, has been giving some thought to internet piracy. The conference, in South Korea last week, and involving reps from Japan, the US and the European Union, among many others, was discussing the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement, a global agreement that has been in development for two years now.

The talks have been rather secretive, but leaked documents show that online piracy, and ways to combat it, was very much on the agenda. And, as has been the trend of late, many representatives there saw the internet service providers as the people who could and should be stopping the infringement of intellectual property rights on the net.

Among the proposals discussed last week was some sort of global three-strikes rule, and a restriction of the so called "safe harbour" provisions of copyright law (to use the American jargon) which offer ISPs protection from infringement claims even when their servers and networks are used by others to infringe.

Three-strikes - whereby ISPs are forced to suspend or disconnect net users who fail to stop file-sharing unlicensed content after two warnings - has been controversial in all the territories where it has been seriously considered. As I remember it, only New Zealand and France have actually made the system law, though neither country's three-strike procedures are yet active. It looks increasingly likely, of course, that some sort of three-strike system will also be introduced here in the UK.

With ISPs the world over (well, outside of Hull - remember the Karoo story?) resistant to any proposals they take on more responsibility for combating online piracy, most in the content industries now recognise new laws are needed to force net firms to act. Of course if "safe harbour" type protection was removed so that ISPs would be liable for so called authorising or contributory infringement by allowing others to use their networks to infringe, the net firms would have to act even if no three-strikes system was actually in place.

The secrecy of the talks does seem rather strange, though with the strength of the ISP lobby and the volume of online opposition to any draconian policing of the internet, it may well be that those involved in ACTA don't want to garner too much attention until their proposals are formalised. Certainly if those proposals do cover internet piracy as well physical product counterfeiting, then they will prove more controversial when they get to treaty stage. Moves to stop kids file-sharing are always going to be more emotive than laws to stop market traders selling knocked off DVDs and dodgy sports kits.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy