Top of the Pop’s producer Chris Cowey has told the FT that the UK singles chart is in the hands of the major labels and as a result is not a reflection of the most popular songs in the country. He said the official top 40 was "dysfunctional" and "often full of crap” and that his show was "successful in spite of the Top 40 chart, not because of it".
He explained that most songs make it into the top 10 because their record companies have used "clever marketing practices" and "not because they are popular". He continued: "One week a record will be there because it is being sold at a discount and the next it's out of the chart because they've raised the price. There's so much great music around and people are listening to it, but the charts are often full of crap. The Top 40 hasn't got credibility."
Cowey proposes that value of sales, rather than volume, be used to calculate the chart because this would prevent record companies discounting singles. He also reckons radio and TV play should be considered – akin the rival Pepsi Chart and the Amercian Billboard Top 50.
The Official UK Singles Chart who collate the chart, a company co-owned by the British Association of Record Dealers and the BPI, told the BBC it was examining the possibility of including digital downloads in its figures. "Five years from now digital delivery will certainly be significant enough to be included in the data that makes the charts," chart director Omar Maskatiya said.
Cowey’s comments come as the flagship BBC pop show reaches its 2000 edition this week.