It took a few days for the video blockade to noticeably kick in, but if you search for music videos by most major artists on YouTube in the UK this morning you'll invariably get the "not available in your country" line as the Google-owned video service's dispute with British publishing royalties body PRS For Music starts to bite.
As much previously reported, Google last week decided to block access to all premium music videos on YouTube in the UK, even though it has licensing deals in place with three of the four major record companies, because its licence renewal talks with PRS For Music - who represent the songwriters and publishers, the owners of two of the four copyrights that exist in most pop promos (the music and the lyrics) - have been faltering. PRS say they were happy for YouTube to continue to stream music videos while talks continued, but Google bosses decided to pull them anyway, presumably in a bid to strong arm the royalties body into agreeing to a less favourable deal, and maybe to secure public support in their bid to persuade the collecting society to play ball.
As also previously reported, Google argue that PRS For Music is now asking for too much money for the rights to stream music by the songwriters they represent, and that their demands make the whole YouTube business model unviable because advertising revenues would never cover the costs of hosting the content. PRS For Music argue that the rates they are proposing are based on those set by the UK's Copyright Tribunal in a previous dispute between the collecting society's and various streaming music services, and that Google is just trying to build their business and boost their profits without paying a fair price for the music that is essential to that business.
Although the Music Publishers Association issued a statement that sort of supported PRS shortly after YouTube announced the video blockade last week, it was generally left to the artist community to criticise Google in the media, mainly because they were conveniently doing the rounds of the TV studios anyway to promote the official launch of their Featured Artist Coalition. The music business at large, including the record companies, who will potentially lose revenue when access to their videos is blocked by YouTube, made little comment.
Until Friday that is, when UK Music, the newish trade body that in theory speaks for the record companies, music publishers and artist managers, issued a statement very much backing the PRS, calling Google "cynical and exploitative", and accusing them of using "counter-productive negotiation tactics" in a bid to force the songwriting community to accept a deal which essentially sees them subsidising a multi-billion dollar company.
The statement from the Feargal Sharkey headed UK Music read: "Great music attracts an audience. This has always been true, and it is true now, more so than ever. Internet start-ups have quickly learned that they can build huge user-numbers by offering access to our members' music. Creativity is the lifeblood of the digital economy. Such popularity is also proof of music's huge intrinsic value. Without this high quality raw material - generated by the endeavours and creativity of our songwriters, composers, artists and musicians and all those who invest in them - sites such as YouTube would be somewhat less compelling. However, whether online or offline, demands that our creative talent should subsidise someone else's business model is as unreasonable as it is inappropriate".
It continued: "Licensing embryonic start-ups has brought significant challenges to all creative businesses. There still are challenges - for both sides - although they can and will be overcome. A huge diversity of licensed digital music services are already active in the UK, and as an industry we remain committed to growing the future of our business. Google, however, qualifies as neither embryonic nor a start-up. In 2008 alone, the internet search giant recorded profits of over £3bn. By comparison, PRS For Music is a not-for-profit organisation, run by its members for its members. In this light, it is difficult but to interpret Google's actions this week as anything other than cynical and exploitative. Such unheralded and counter-productive negotiation tactics are not only detrimental to music fans, but also to the UK's songwriters and composers".
With the video blockade only now really coming into effect, and with tough talking like this suggesting there won't be a quick resolution to this dispute, it will be interesting to see what impact the removal of videos from YouTube has on all parties. We all know music videos are among the most popular kind of content on YouTube, and more savvy web users will quickly find other sources of pop promo content, possibly on unlicensed streaming sites or file-sharing networks where record companies and music publishers receive zero for their content.
That said, there are other music video services, including the increasingly expansive MUZU TV, who last week criticised their rivals over their squabble with PRS and added that their own business model accommodated the collecting society's standard rates. And, of course, there is Spotify, the on-demand audio streaming service with an ever growing catalogue which, although not quite as all-encompassing as YouTube, is pretty damn big. True, it's audio not video, though given that until recently there were no expansive, truly on-demand, free and legal audio streaming services, I think there's a very high chance people were attracted to music videos on YouTube more because of the easy-access to songs rather than the visuals of the videos.
That is to say, if the YouTube/PRS stand off proves to be long term, it will be interesting to see who loses out - everybody, or primarily Google. If the latter, that's gotta effect the video services' power at the negotiating table with labels and publishers all over the world.