Sep 19, 2005 • 1 min read

US court ruling may affect RIAA's legal fight against young downloaders

A Michigan judge has ruled that Candy Chan cannot be held liable for her 13-year-old child's file sharing, a decision that could affect the RIAA's strategy against parents.

Staying in the copyright courts, and a ruling in a Michigan court might have a wider effect on the Recording Industry Association Of America's legal fight against individuals who they suspect of illegally sharing music online via P2P networks like Kazaa - well, mainly those not old enough to vote.

The RIAA has so far been suing the parents of children who they suspect to be illegally sharing music online on the basis that, as the legal guardians of said children, they are responsible for ensuring they do not violate copyright online. While that strategy has won the industry association some bad press, industry bosses hoped they had overcome some of the initial problems with a marketing campaign making parents aware of the risks of letting their children share music via P2P.

However, a judge in the District Court Eastern District of Michigan Southern Division has decided the whole premise of that strategy is false. In the case of Priority Records LLC et al v Chan the labels accepted that the guilty party was not computer illiterate Candy Chan, but her 13 year old child. However, they insist that Ms Chan was still ultimately responsible for the copyright theft. However, Judge Lawrence Zatkoff disagreed, saying Ms Chan could not be held liable for her daughter's actions in this case.

Having also put in place restrictions to protect the child in question from litigation, Zatkoff's ruling could prove problematic for the RIAA in their bid to stop teenagers from sharing music online - which is particularly problematic because teenagers are some of the worst offenders. Of course the decision was made in a junior court and it is yet to be seen if the ruling would be applied in other cases. However, Zatkoff's decision might persuade more parents faced with RIAA litigation to let the case go to court rather than opt for an out-of-court settlement. Interesting times could be ahead.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy