Sep 27, 2004 • 1 min read

US judge questions anti-bootlegging law in dismissed case

A New York judge dismissed charges against a record dealer for selling bootleg concert recordings, ruling the anti-bootlegging law unfairly gave perpetual protection.

A US judge made an interesting decision last week when he dismissed charges against a Manhattan-based record dealer who had been found guilty of selling unofficial recordings of concerts. Jean Martignon was indicted by a federal grand jury back in October 2003 for selling "unauthorised recordings of live performances". However New York based Judge Harold Baer Jr last week overruled that decision on the basis that the law against the creation and sale of bootleg recordings could not stand because "it placed no time limit on the ban - unlike the limits placed on books or recorded music releases". Baer concluded that meant that US law unfairly granted "seemingly perpetual protection" to the original performances.

Prosecutors in the case are now "reviewing the decision", although the Recording Industry Association Of America were quick to criticise the judge's viewpoint. Spokesman Jonathan Lamy told reporters: "It stands in marked contrast to existing law and prior decisions that have determined that Congress was well within its constitutional authority to adopt legislation that prevented trafficking in copies of unauthorised performances of live music".

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy