Jun 17, 2008 • 1 min read

US musicians' union sues American Idol over rerun recordings

The American Federation of Musicians is suing American Idol's producers over re-recorded music for the Rewind reruns, seeking fees and an injunction.

The American Federation Of Musicians, basically the US' Musicians Union, is suing the makers of 'American Idol' over the rerecording of music for a rerun of the popular TV talent show. Or something like that, it's all a bit confusing really.

The dispute centres on 'American Idol Rewind', a repeat of the main pop reality programme that airs on various US TV networks after the main series and competition is done and dusted. I think the problem is that, in order to avoid having to pay the musicians whose music appeared on the original version of the show a second fee based on a union agreement (75% of the original fee and a pension fund contribution), producers had the music rerecorded by new musicians under a new agreement more favourable to the TV makers. The union says they weren't informed of this until after the fact, and that the second agreement violated another collective bargaining agreement. I think I'm right in saying the lawsuit relates specifically to the second series of 'American Idol'.

The union is suing in a bid to have the musicians whose music appeared on the main 'American Idol' series paid a fee for the repeat series, even though their music didn't actually appear on it. They are also looking for damages and legal fees, oh, and an injunction to stop TV producers switching music on reruns to avoid royalty payments again in the future.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy