Warner Music is facing an interesting lawsuit in the US which could potentially alter the value digital download revenue streams have for the average record label.
Singer Tom Waits and his management firm Third Story Music have launched litigation against the major record company over the share of digital download revenues that they receive. Third Story argue that download sales should be classified under 'third-party licensed revenues' rather than 'direct sale' because there is no physical product being sold. The distinction is crucial because under two contracts between Waits and Warners the singer gets a much bigger cut on any revenues created through third party licensing - up to 50%.
Needless to say, Warner argue that download sales do count as 'direct sales', even though they do not necessarily fit what would have been defined as 'direct sales' back in the seventies. Therefore revenue splits should be on the same level as with CD sales.
Following Waits' lawsuit it will now be left for the courts to decide where download sales should slot in. If they find in favour of Waits and Third Story, hundreds of other established artists are sure to return to their early contracts and see if they should be receiving a bigger cut of download sales, which will not be good news for the record labels.