May 16, 2005 • 2 min read

Would you consider an iPod tax?

Former Chrysalis and BMG boss Doug D'Arcy backs a levy on MP3 players to compensate labels for piracy, a model being approved in Holland but opposed by the IFPI.

Talking of idle speculation about the future of digital music - iPod tax anyone? Yep, with both the music industry's legal assault on P2P users and the record labels' use of ever more complex anti-piracy protection on CDs coming under increasing criticism, a new version of an old idea has been put forward to help the music business overcome the commercial problems caused by the online file sharing - an iPod tax.

The idea is that a levy should be added to ever MP3 player sold that is passed on to the record labels to compensate them for revenues lost because of online file sharing. The idea is similar to that adopted in some European countries when tape-to-tape music piracy first became an issue in the late seventies - they charged an extra tax on the sale of blank audio cassettes and, more recently, CDRs.

The idea is being discussed now because such a copyright levy is in the process of being approved in Holland, where consumers could soon have to pay an extra sum of money each time they buy an MP3 player which will then be passed onto the record companies via a new royalty collections agency.

Speaking to Scottish newspaper the Sunday Herald, former Chrysalis and BMG boss Doug D'Arcy supports the proposal, seeing it as the only viable way for record labels to tackle the growing problem of online piracy. D'Arcy: "The illegal digital download market is in danger of crippling the British music industry and unless something is done to address this quickly, it will spell disaster for thousands of artists and independent record labels. We had an opportunity to introduce a levy on audio cassettes back in the 1970s and passed it up. That decision cost the business tens of millions, and to make the same mistake again could be fatal. It's time to get real. Digital piracy is spiralling out of control and there's no way that we can effectively police it. The levy system is proven, and by charging consumers up front for something they are going to do anyway we would at least be able to recoup a portion of the revenues currently being lost to piracy."

However, the proposals are being criticised by some key players in the music industry. Some argue the levy system penalises those people who use their digital music players exclusively to play tracks they have ripped from their own CD collection or that they have bought from a legal download platform. Others argue the system legitimises online music piracy. Olivia Regnier of the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry's Europe office told the Herald: "This is not something we support and is in fact a strategy that has already been rejected for Britain. The levies that already exist are intended as a means to collect charges incurred by people making back-up copies of copyright material they have already bought. They are not to be taken as a justification for piracy and are not an appropriate response to the problem."

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy