A Parisian appeals court has rejected an earlier court ruling which said that Universal Music should give back French rock singer Johnny Hallyday all the rights to his past recordings.
The original court ruling followed allegations made by Hallyday that at the start of his career the record label forced him into contracts that meant he was then indebted to them financially, enabling them to force him into future projects and contracts.
The courts gave Hallyday back the rights to his music and ordered an independent assessor to look into the various contracts that had been drawn up between Universal and the singer.
But yesterday a court in Paris overturned that decision after Universal appealed, claiming that it was setting a dangerous precedent for the courts to allow recording artists to undo past contracts once they were rich and famous. Doing so, they argued, could affect the number of companies and individuals willing to invest money in breaking talent.
In overturning the decision the courts forced Hallyday to stick to his existing contract with Universal which runs until the end of the year. He will have to produce one more album for the label, and will not be able to release another record with a different label until 2007. The courts said that while Hallyday's back catalogue will stay with Universal, he could record and release new versions of those tracks after 2007, but that a fee would have to be paid to Universal to do so.