The creative and media industries in Australia have come together to demand that the country’s government resist calls from big tech to change copyright law to make it easier for AI companies to use existing content for AI training without getting permission from creators and rightsholders.
They are backing a new campaign under the banner Not AI’s To Take, which has been launched ahead of the Australian record industry’s big ARIA Awards show tomorrow evening.
It comes amid growing concerns within the Australian creative and media industries that ministers there are considering copyright reforms that would basically allow AI companies to make use of existing content in their AI training with getting permission first, except where a rights owner has formally opted out.
It’s a similar proposal to that made by the UK government in late 2024, a plan that British ministers then abandoned earlier this year. A website for the new Not AI’s To Take campaign declares that Australia’s creative and media sectors “contribute $70.3 billion to our economy and employ almost 600,000 workers”. It then states that “foreign AI shouldn’t use our creative work without permission and payment”.
Among those supporting the campaign in the music industry is collecting society APRA, whose CEO Dean Ormston says that “a mutually beneficial relationship between big tech and the world’s creative industries should be a no-brainer”, but that’s not being achieved because “big tech assumed it could avoid asking permission or paying for the most important ingredient in its platforms: creative content”.
The job of the government, he goes on, “isn’t to shield AI companies from the consequences of taking creators’ work”. Instead it should seek to get AI companies to the negotiating table to secure the relevant licences. “If a deal falls over because the terms don't stack up or creators won’t opt in”, he goes on, “that’s a commercial consequence, not a reason to rewrite the law”.
The copyright obligations of AI companies have been the subject of much political and legal debate around the world, of course, with lots of lobbying and litigation along the way, and dozens of lawsuits still working their way through the courts in various different countries.
Many AI companies reckon they should be able to copy large quantities of existing creative works - whether text, image, video, audio or music - as part of their AI training processes without getting permission from creators or rightsholders.
In the US, they argue AI training is fair use, meaning permission isn’t necessary. In other countries they are looking for specific exceptions in copyright law to cover AI training, usually a ‘text and data mining’ - or TDM - exception.
The copyright industries - including the music industry - argue that if AI companies want to use existing content to train AI models, they should seek and negotiate licences from the relevant rights owners.
While that will take time and cost quite a lot of money, licensing frameworks already exist, and AI companies are already spending billions to develop their technologies, while the major players in the AI business either have or seek multi-trillion dollar valuations.
While the UK government was proposing a new TDM exception in late 2024 - albeit with the option for rightsholders to opt-out, meaning permission would still be required to use those rightsholders’ works - ministers in Australia were adamant they wouldn’t be weakening copyright law for the benefit of the AI sector.
Last October, the country’s Attorney-General Michelle Rowland told ABC that - while there was definitely work to be done reviewing Australian copyright law in the context of AI - “we are making it very clear that we will not be entertaining a text and data mining exception”.
And as recently as July, Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said, “no company should use Australian books, music, art or news to build or train AI without the artist’s control. That includes the artist’s control of the price and value of their work. Anything less, is theft”.
However, while the UK government formally dropped its plans for a new TDM copyright exception back in March, in recent months it has been widely reported that the Australian government is now actively considering changes to copyright law to help AI companies.
The changes being considered would not be framed as a TDM exception, allowing Rowland to technically stand by her previous commitment. However, introducing any new requirement for rightsholders to opt their works out of AI training would basically be the same thing.
There is also talk of AI companies making some sort of payment into a collective licensing system to cover any works that are not formally opted out, which would basically be a form of compulsory licensing. That approach is also strongly opposed by the creative and media industries.
The shift in position in Australia follows fierce lobbying from big tech and the AI sector, which argues that Australia’s current copyright regime will prevent many AI companies from investing in the country. Which is a position strongly rejected by the music and wider copyright industries.
In the UK, creators and rightsholders across the music, film, TV, book, newspaper and visual art sectors came together to successfully campaign against the UK government’s proposals for a new AI-friendly TDM exception. This new campaign in Australia hopes to do something similar to block the copyright reforms now being considered there.
Music organisations involved include collecting societies APRA AMCOS and PPCA, plus industry organisations ARIA, Artists Alliance Of Australia, Association Of Artist Managers, Australasian Music Publishers' Association, Australian Guild Of Screen Composers, Music Producer & Engineers’ Guild and the Australian Independent Record Labels Association.