ISPS REACH COMPROMISE TO HELP LABELS FIGHT P2P COPYRIGHT VIOLATION
Now here's an interesting idea - compromise. Internet service providers in the Netherlands have reached a compromise with the record labels there regarding the campaign against the illegal sharing of copyright music via P2P platforms like Kazaa and Grokster.
As previously reported, record labels can only trace illegal file sharing to the IP addresses of the guilty parties - the internet service providers hold the key to the actual identities of those individuals. Music industry associations have tried to use copyright legislation to force ISPs to hand over that contact information as a matter of course.
However internet service providers are cautious in making the identities of their consumers known to third parties, officially because they don't want to run the risk of falsely accusing their customers
(the way record labels identify copyright violation isn't completely reliable) and, it might be argued, also because the existence of P2P networks has been a useful tool for ISPs in driving up the sales of broadband.
For a time in the US the courts forced the ISPs to automatically hand over the contact information of suspected copyright violators, however that decision was later overruled. Now the record labels have to begin legal action against individual lawsuits as 'John
Doe' cases, proving to the courts an IP address is being used for copyright violation before launching litigation against the specific individual. This makes the whole process much more expensive and time consuming.
As a way of compromise five Dutch ISPs have agreed to send warning letters to any of its customers the music industry suspects of violating copyright via P2P networks. This letter will be drafted by the Brain Institute, with represents various Dutch labels and entertainment companies. If customers can be shown to have ignored one of those warning letters the ISP will assist to an extent in the record label's attempts to proceed with legal action.
It remains to be seen if that compromise is adopted elsewhere - the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry did recently appeal to ISPs across Europe to work with them in their fight against online copyright theft.